Archive for the ‘Subscribe to my Feeds’ Category

Minister’s ‘disabling’ cheek

Thursday, April 24th, 2008

A press release from the Gibraltar Local Disability Movement (GLDM) should make embarassing reading for one GSD (Gibraltar Social Democrats) Minister today.

The GLDM are ‘whistleblowing’ on a Government Minister after they received a complaint from one of their members regarding the experience they had when trying to park their car in the parking bays allocated for the disabled at St Bernard’s Hospital.

The GLDM statement explains that when the parents of a disabled child arrived at the St Bernard’s Hospital car park, they found all the disabled parking bays were already taken. Looking around the cars, they thought they would check if they all had the Blue Badge, a Permit that entitles car owners to use the disabled bays. They found one car that did not have the Blue Badge displayed on the vehicle.

Yvette Del Agua - GSD MP and Minister of Health and Civil ProtectionInvestigating further, to their amazement, they learned that the owner of the car was none other than GSD MP Yvette Del Agua, currently the Minister for Health and Civil Protection in the Gibraltar Government.


Minister del Agua's car parked in a restricted Blue Badge only car parking space - Car registration masked for her personal securty but the car's ownership has been verified
It seems, apparently from what the Disabled child’s parents understand from Hospital sources, that when the Minister’s parking bay is being obstructed by other vehicles, Mrs del Agua sees fit to park her car in a disabled parking bay… as can be seen from the photographic evidence to that effect!

Surely, as a former Minister for Social Affairs herself, one would think she, above everyone else, would know better. As the GLDM statement says:


The Minister whose responsibilities are Public Health, Medical & Health Services, and Civil Contingencies amongst others should know better, if somebody who supports or speaks in favour of the disabled is not seen setting an example, how can we encourage raising people’s awareness on something that are, respecting the needs of the disabled, parents of a disabled child asks itself.

The GLDM take a very serious and one would imagine dim view of this. They have decided that the event should be highlighted and made public “with the objective of awareness, and to bring to the attention the problems that Blue Badge holders have”.

As usual with this lot… it seems there’s one law for some and another law for others and the disabled can wait in line, and forget their Blue Badges!

Source: Gibraltar Local Disability Movement (GLDM) -Press Release - 24 April 2008

Related Articles and Links:

Social Services Agency

Gibraltar Health Authority (GHA)

Read more Articles and News reports about Social Services in Gibraltar

Comment on this News report in our Forum Topic

Government to finally introduce EU wide ‘Blue Badge’ disabled parking scheme

Monday, April 2nd, 2007


Gibraltar Government Press Office - No 6 Convent Place
The Gibraltar Government announced today the introduction of a ‘Blue Badge Scheme’ for the disabled.


A disabled parking sign in Torrens, Australian Capital Territory - 20th January 2007 - Photo courtesy of Tim Malone, www.timmalone.id.au
The scheme will be implemented as from Tuesday 10th April 2007.

In a press statement today, the Government Press Office said the implementation of the new scheme will mean that disability discs issued will be in the format of the EU style Blue Badge Scheme.

Discs will either be issued to an individual or to an institution that cares for the disabled. They have been printed to comply with EU specifications and are governed by the Disabled Persons (Badges for Motor Vehicles) Regulations. These are a new set of regulations that have been specifically drafted by the Government to govern the issue, administration and enforcement of the scheme. The responsibility for the issue and administration of the scheme has now been transferred to the Department of Transport.

A medical panel is being constituted to adjudicate on each application. This panel will comprise a doctor, an occupational therapist and government officials. It is anticipated that this panel will meet on a monthly basis to consider all new applications.

In order not to inconvenience current badge holders, the Government will automatically replace their current badge with a new one issued under this new scheme. Each holder of a current badge will be written to individually to inform them accordingly. Current Disability Disc holders will be asked to fill out a questionnaire and return it together with two passport-sized photographs to the Department of Transport. They will then be issued with a new disability badge.

The Minister with responsibility for Transport has met the Chairperson of the Disability Society and the Chairperson of the Society for the Visually Impaired to consult them on the details and the introduction of the new scheme.

Commenting on the launch of the Blue Badge Scheme, Deputy Chief Minister Joe Holliday, the Minister with responsibility for Transport, said:


“I am delighted that the ‘Blue Badge Scheme’ will be introduced in Gibraltar next week.

The Scheme will enable those who are eligible, to use the Scheme both in Gibraltar and across Europe.

This is great news for those with Disability Permits.

I would like to take this opportunity to thank the Traffic Commission, which for many years has had the responsibility for the issuing of Disability Discs.”

Application forms and information on the Blue Badge Scheme may be obtained from any of the following:

    The Department of Transport, Motor Vehicle Test Centre, Eastern Beach Road

    Royal Gibraltar Police (RGP) Headquarters, New Mole House or Central Police Station in Irish Town

    Citizens’ Advice Bureau, 10 Governor’s Lane, Gibraltar

Additionally, and as from Tuesday 10th April, members of the public can visit the Government of Gibraltar website, where they will be able to obtain further details of the scheme, as well as downloading the application forms.

Source: Gibraltar Government Press Release - 02 April 2007 - No: 75/2007

Related Articles and Links:

The Blue Badge parking scheme : Directgov UK - Disabled people

Disabled Person’s Parking Permit - The Blue Badge parking scheme - Information from Wikipedia, the free encyclopaedia

15 March 2007 - La Linea Ayuntamiento to recognise Gibraltar disabled parking badges

14 March 2007 - Juarez meets Gibraltar Disability Society

Read more Articles and News stories about Disability issues in Gibraltar

Read more Articles and News Reports about or related to the Gibraltar Local Disability Movement

Comment on this News report - Click on the ‘Comments’ link below - You can also Discuss this Story in our Forum

Juarez meets Gibraltar Disability Society

Wednesday, March 14th, 2007

Disability issues in GibraltarLa Linea mayor Juan Carlos Juárez, yesterday met a delegation from the local Disability Society to discuss the problems faced by disabled persons in obtaining car parking spaces in La Linea.


D. Juan Carlos Juárez Arriola is the Mayor or Alcalde Presidente of the Ayuntamiento de La Línea de la Concepción, the local government authority in Gibraltar's neighbouring Spanish town
This is a long-standing difficulty faced by Gibraltarians with disability when driving in the neighbouring city, said the Gibraltar Chronicle today.

A spokesperson for Sr Juarez said:


“We have agreed to study the possibility that ‘disabled’ discs used in Gibraltar can also be used in La Linea, so they can park in the spaces that are reserved for such purposes.”

The spokesperson added that as a result of the meeting, and in order to improve the situation, the Ayuntamiento de La Línea de la Concepción, the local government in La Linea, will be increasing the number of parking spaces reserved for the disabled in the city centre and in the car parks close to La Linea’s beaches.

The meeting was also attended by the councillor for security issues Francisco Muñiz, who is in charge of the local police and the Ayuntamiento advisor on Gibraltar issues Juan Carmona.

Source: The Gibraltar Chronicle

Related Articles and Links:

Ayuntamiento de La Línea de la Concepción

Gibraltar Local Disability Movement (GLDM)

Read more Articles and News stories about Disability issues in Gibraltar

Read more Articles and News Reports about or related to the Gibraltar Local Disability Movement

Comment on this News report - Click on the ‘Comments’ link below - You can also Discuss this Story in our Forum

GGR complains to EU over Government failure to set up Equal Opportunities Commission

Tuesday, November 28th, 2006

Gibraltar's Equality Rights Group GGRThe Equality Rights Group GGR have disclosed today, that they are in discussions with the EU President, José Manuel Barroso, over the Gibraltar Government’s failure to set up an Equal Opportunities Commission in Gibraltar.


European Commission President José Manuel Barroso - in discussions with Gibraltar's GGR over Government failure to set up Equal Opportunities Commission in Gibraltar</a/></p>
<p>GGR Chairman Felix Alvarez reveals that they have complained directly to the EU President, asking him to take action “against the Gibraltar Government for failing to implement the requirements of EU law with regards to the establishment of an Equal Opportunities Commission in Gibraltar.  Mr Alvarez added that the GGR have also been in contact with the EU Commission “over some time and covering various issues”.</p>
<p>The GGR said that the establishment of an Equal Opportunities Commission should have been implemented along with the </a><a href=Equal Opportunities Ordinance
“some years back”.

Mr Alvarez said:


“We still have not seen this legal requirement materialise, even following the recent trumpeting by Government of measures required by the EU in the relevant Ordinance and certainly not as an act of political goodwill on their part as they would have us believe.”

The GGR say the Government’s recent announcement of its plans to implement pending measures to the relevant EU Directive makes “no reference to this equally pending legal obligation on their part”.


“In the light of Mr Caruana’s “Africanisation” remarks, the requirement for a Commission to act as a watchdog against incipient racism is all the more relevant.”

Mr Alvarez was referring to remarks made by the Chief Minister, Peter Caruana, speaking in the House of Assembly, during a debate on the proposed new Draft Gibraltar Constitution, when Mr Caruana criticised “those who suggest that the independence of the local judiciary needs to be adjudicated upon by a lawyer who represented Steve Biko, and fought for the dismantling of the apartheid system in South Africa. Mr Caruana accused those who wish to ‘africanise‘ the assessment of the judicial system and “to taint by association” the Rock’s reputation as a law abiding country for the past 300 years, of doing “a huge disservice to Gibraltar”.

Mr Alvarez said that “there is no doubt that Mr Caruana’s remarks caused offence”.


“They caused offence for the nuances he attached to the term he used and local African citizens in Gibraltar were, in our view, naturally aggrieved at what was perceived as a derogatory attitude.”

Mr Alvarez said the GGR will continue to insist upon the EU at its highest administrative and political levels that “European law must form a part of our responsibilities in the same way that European rights are conferred and our letter highlights this point”.

Age of consent for gay citizens

“Additionally,” Mr Alvarez added, “we continue to raise the issue of an unequal age of consent for gay citizens in Gibraltar”.


“That this should continue to be a fact of local law whilst the European Court of Human Rights and the Treaty of Rome on which the EU is founded clearly disapprove of such discrimination and inequality is a measure of how behind the times the political establishment continues to be on issues of human and social rights.”

Gibraltar’s exclusion from disabled passengers Air travel legislation

Mr Alvarez also referred to the issue of Gibraltar’s exclusion from the EU’s disabled passengers Air travel legislation.


Equality Rights Group Chairman Felix Alvarez (right) during his visit to Brussels in January when he met EU Justice Commissioner Franco Frattini. Mr Alvarez was supported and hosted by various MEPs including Graham Watson Liberal MEP for Gibraltar and the South West Region of the UK
In January this year, the GGR Chairman visited the European Commission in Brussels and received assurances from EU Commissioner Franco Frattini that he would review the EU directive on air travel and the Disabled and Gibraltar’s exclusion from it.

The GGR have asked the European Commission and President Barroso, “for feedback” regarding the status of a Gibraltarian citizen’s petition to the EU, regarding the effect of the Spanish veto of the EU legislation which resulted in excluding disabled persons using Gibraltar airport from directly accessing airport facilities on an equal basis to similar citizens in other EU territories, as the legislation grants.

Today, Mr Alvarez said that the GGR recognises that the Tripartite Dialogue Forum’s Cordoba Accord Airport Agreement may have affected the situation.


“It is by no means clear to what extent Spain will now lift its vetos on Gibraltar-effective EU air measures. It is for this reason that we have asked for clarification.”

Concluding his statement, Mr Alvarez also revealed that the GGR have been working on these and many other issues affecting Gibraltar’s equality and human rights “for a significant period of time”. He said it is likely, that in the coming months, “important meetings at very high levels” may take place to which he will be a party, with both UK and EU decision makers, in order to “mark progress on the human rights front in Gibraltar”.

Source: Equality Rights Group GGR Press Release - 23 November 2006

Related Articles and Links:

Council Directive 2000/78/EC of 27 November 2000 | Establishing a general framework for equal treatment in employment and occupation

EU - Employment, Social affairs and Equal opportunities - Anti-discrimination and relations with Civil Society

European Commission’s website on anti-discrimination

Laws of Gibraltar

27 November 2006 - Government provides more information on Equal Opportunities Bill

23 November 2006 - Government publishes Equal Opportunities Bill to end age and disability discrimination

23 November 2006 - GGR calls on Government to implement anti age and disability discrimination law

26 January 2006 - EU Commissioners to review Gibraltar’s exclusion from disabled passengers Air travel legislation

Read more Articles and News reports about Disability issues in Gibraltar

Read more Articles and News reports about or related to Human Rights in Gibraltar

Read more Articles and News reports about the politics surrounding Gibraltar Airport

Read more Articles and News reports about the Tripartite Dialogue Forum

Read more Articles and News reports about or related to the Equality Rights Group GGR

My Gibraltar Directory - Website Directory of Gibraltar and the Campo de Gibraltar

Comment on this News report - Click on the ‘Comments’ link below - You can also Discuss this Story in our Forum

Government publishes Equal Opportunities Bill to end age and disability discrimination

Thursday, November 23rd, 2006

Disabled and Age Discrimination


Gibraltar Government Press Office - No 6 Convent Place
The Gibraltar Government has announced the publication of a wide-ranging Bill for an Equal Opportunities Ordinance that will ban discrimination against age and disabled persons.

The disabled and age discrimination does not currently enjoy the protection of legislation that prevents the possible discrimination of these at work or in education. The proposed ordinance addresses these issues and simply transposes a EU Council Directive establishing a general framework for equal treatment in employment and occupation, which dates back six years to November 2000, into Gibraltar law.

The new legislation should tackle many of the concerns highlighted by the Disability Society, and Gibraltar’s Equality Rights Group GGR. These issues came to the fore particularly last summer when many expressed dissatisfaction about disability issues and the absence of any legislation.

The Government has ‘nothing to trumpet about’ say GGR

Today’s Chronicle says the Ordinance will include specific measures relating to disabled persons that go beyond the simple protection of the individual. However, some groups, especially the GGR, disagree. The Government has “nothing to trumpet in this respect” said the GGR today.

“The provisions it says it is introducing are, in the context of Gibraltar’s appalling and backward situation regarding the disabled.


These are helpful, though severely limited measures, that the Government has been forced to introduce by the EU and not as a part of any Government initiative or political goodwill.”

The proposed Bill states:


“In relation to discrimination on the grounds of disability, discrimination also includes a failure to make reasonable adjustments to modify premises and practices to ensure that disabled persons are not substantially disadvantaged.”

The new law will also prohibit discrimination against pregnant women or nursing mothers. It is designed to bolster the current Equal Opportunities Ordinance of 2004, which makes it unlawful for employers and educators to discriminate on the grounds of sex, religion, belief, racial or ethnic origin, or sexual orientation.

The proposed Equal Opportunities Ordinance of 2006 will clarify and streamline the relationship between local employment law and the 2004 equal opportunities legislation.

It also reinforces legislation ensuring the equal treatment of men and women as regards access to jobs and training, as well as working conditions.

Time is running out

The Bill should come into force by the 2nd December, as required by the EU Directive. However, the bill still has to be debated by the House of Assembly, before the legislation can be approved by the House.

The Equality Rights Group GGR, in a statment today, has reminded the Government and affected citizens that the provisions for combating age and disability discrimination in employment in the Equal Opportunities Ordinance must be put into effect by 2nd December.

The GGR said they welcome the fact that the Government has announced the publication of this Bill today and that the Bill brings the required extensions to the Equal Opportunities Ordinance”. Nevertheless, the GGR added:


“Citizens in this community should note that, irrespective of whether Government presents the new provisions to the House of Assembly in time or not, both the disabled and those who feel discriminated on the basis of age and in relation to employment should note that as from 2nd December this year, these provisions will be theirs by right.

Any person who suffers discrimination on these grounds as of that date will be in a position to sue the Government for damages which may have resulted from non-implementation.”

The GGR say they encourage individuals to “exercise their rightful legal rights”.


“This is especially in cases where citizens may suffer as a result of Government failure to carry out their legal obligations in regard to EU law.

The GGR will lend support to such persons.”

The GGR added that at the time when the Equal Opportunities Ordinance was debated in the House of Assembly, now almost 3 years ago, Mr Caruana indicated he intended to bring forward the implementation of these measures, “though technically the deadline is reached on 2nd December”.


“It is clear that Mr Caruana has not seen fit to give the matter the importance it deserves and so we are once more, and on a technicality, brought to the brink on these issues.”

Nonetheless, the GGR say they trust the Government will ensure implementation takes place on time but add that they hope the Government’s new legislation goes much further than the EU Directive requires them to:


“Furthermore, it is still to be seen whether Government has taken the opportunity with these already-trumpeted provisions to genuinely go beyond the measures provided for by the EU Directive through not only introducing these very limited anti-disability and anti-age measures for the workplace, but to establish a clear, comprehensive and progressive legislative framework, via an Ordinance, which will once and for all bring Gibraltar into line with the rest of Europe with respect to not only general anti-discrimination measures for our citizens, but also specific, binding, and published rates of allowances and social security support for this part of our population.”

The GGR said, in a “normal European setting and departing from an already decent base of measures (which Gibraltar does not have) to support the disabled, these extra provisions are undoubtedly welcome”.


“Given the appalling state of affairs in Gibraltar, where disability is recognised only when derived from birth and not thereafter, for the Government to trumpet its ‘success’ when merely introducing measures related to employment alone and, furthermore, not as an act of initiative and volition but in response to sheer legal obligation arising from the EU and not from its own policies, it will be obvious to all that any trumpeting of new measures sounds a flat and dischordant note!”

The GGR say it is “not good enough for people to have to be at the mercy of unknown, ambiguous and hidden behind-the-counter support and benefits, which are difficult to verify and even more difficult to challenge by citizens”.


“It is only when we act in an up-front and right manner towards our most vulnerable that Gibraltar can rest at ease with its conscience as to how we treat our friends and family members who happen to be disabled or of a certain age.”

Source: Equality Rights Group GGR Press Release - 23 November 2006 | The Gibraltar Chronicle

Related Articles and Links:

Council Directive 2000/78/EC of 27 November 2000 | Establishing a general framework for equal treatment in employment and occupation

Laws of Gibraltar

Read more Articles and News reports about Disability issues in Gibraltar

Read more Articles and News reports about or related to Senior Citizens in Gibraltar

Read more Articles and News reports about or related to Human Rights in Gibraltar

Read more Articles and News reports about or related to the Equality Rights Group GGR

My Gibraltar Directory - Website Directory of Gibraltar and the Campo de Gibraltar

Comment on this News report - Click on the ‘Comments’ link below - You can also Discuss this Story in our Forum

RGP confirm death fall woman’s name

Friday, November 10th, 2006

Updated | Gibraltar Local Disability Movement (GLDM) statement added


Harbour Views - This is the building a young 26 year old woman jumped off a balcony on 9th November 2006
The Royal Gibraltar Police (RGP) today confirmed the name of the young woman involved in the tragic incident yesterday, when she jumped off a balcony at Harbour Views.

The RGP named the 26 year old woman as Sue Ellen Snape.

Speaking to Gibraltar News Online, a spokesperson for the RGP said:


“We can confirm she fell from the ninth floor of Miami Court Harbour Views.

The incident was reported to the police at 09:47 hrs on Thursday 9 November 2006.

She was taken to hospital and pronounced dead there.

A post mortem examination has been carried out and the Coroner has ordered an Inquest.”

Coroner to Investigate Death Fall

The Coroner, Charles Pitto, has now opened an investigation, as is normal in these circumstances and as confirmed by the RGP. A full inquest into the death can be ordered by the Coroner, should he feel it is necessary to do so.

The RGP however, also confirmed that no foul play is suspected.

Earlier, the RGP investigation teams, including the Forensic unit, had cordoned off the area at the base of the building, watched by stunned neighbours, while the forensics team recorded the scene.

Social Services Involvement

The Equality Rights Group GGR have called for a full and independent public investigation into the role the Social Affairs Minister and the Social Services Agency have played in this tragic case.

As has been widely reported, Miss Snape had been at the centre of a bitter row between the Government’s Social Affairs Ministry and the GSLP/Liberals Opposition in recent weeks.

In early October, the Shadow Minister for Social Services, Charles Bruzon said the Opposition were “seriously concerned” regarding the situation facing Sue Ellen Snape. This followed a plea for help from the family, who had insisted they wanted to make the issue public, through the Opposition. The family felt they had “run out of options”.

Mr Bruzon took up the case on their behalf and expressed their “serious misgivings about the degree of support offered by Social Services” to Miss Snape, who had physical and mental disabilities but wanted to live an independent life in her own home.

At the time, Mr Bruzon said he had written to the Government three times since June in order to drive home the urgency of the case. In a public exchange in the local media, the Government insisted that while Social Services could offer some support to the family, it could not provide the specialist care required to enable Ms Snape to live alone.

The GGR, in a strongly worded and sombre statement this morning, called for a full and public investigation to “clarify whether any failure of treatment for this individual has played any role in her death”.

Chairman Felix Alvarez added that should any failure of treatment be found to have been the cause, then the decent thing for the Minister to do is to resign.

The GGR Chairman said that people are “not mere ‘voting capital’ for the politicians”. Mr Alvarez declared that people, in the care of Social Services, “are human beings that need to be cared for and for whom policies have to be built which invest in their well-being and quality of life”. He said that the Chief Minister Peter Caruana and his Government “must assume responsibility for any failure which may have occurred in this tragic case and do the decent thing by instituting an independent enquiry free of political influence or intervention”.


“Following such an act of transparency, or even before it, the decent thing in any democratic State is for the Minister concerned to resign as acknowledgment of Government’s moral responsibility for the welfare of its most vulnerable citizens.”

Disability Movement “deeply saddened”

The Gibraltar Local Disability Movement (GLDM), in a statement this evening, have called the tragic death of Sue Ellen Snape “a sad awakening”. They said this death “could have been avoided” if the Service repeatedly requested, had been made available to this family.

The GLDM asks “what it will take” for the Social Services Agency to provide a service in our community that “is entitled to every one”.

The GLDM also says that the Social Services Agency “must take the recent events to heart”, in the light of the “ineffective Service that is offered” and “come out with a statement informing the community on its involvement, and what measure it is going to take to prevent this happened again”.

The Disability Movement said they are “deeply saddened for the loss to the family and would like to pay its respect to them”.

Related Articles and Links:

GSLP/Liberals Opposition

Social Services Agency

Equality Rights Group GGR

10 November 2006 - GGR calls for full public investigation of reasons behind young woman’s death fall

09 November 2006 - Young woman throws herself off a balcony at Harbour Views

07 November 2006 - Disability Movement urges new premises for Dr Giraldi Home

03 November 2006 - Concerns over Social Services Agency are widespread, say Opposition party

12 October 2006 - GHA and Social Services accuse Opposition of using KGV patient for political gain

05 October 2006 - Bruzon urges greater support for disabled woman

Read more Articles and News reports about Disability issues in Gibraltar

Read more Articles and News reports about Social Services in Gibraltar

Read more Articles and News reports about or related to the Equality Rights Group GGR

Read more Articles and News Reports about or related to the Gibraltar Local Disability Movement

My Gibraltar Directory - Website Directory of Gibraltar and the Campo de Gibraltar

Comment on this News report - Click on the ‘Comments’ link below - You can also Discuss this Story in our Forum

Disability Movement urges new premises for Dr Giraldi Home

Tuesday, November 7th, 2006

Disability Society protest against Government shortcomings on Disability issues in GibraltarThe Gibraltar Local Disability Movement (GLDM) is calling on the Government to re-house the Dr Giraldi Home and the premises for the respite services.

The Gibraltar Local Disability Movement are also warning the Government, that any “favouritism” in allocation of services to the disabled would be illegal.

In a statement yesterday, the GLDM said “it is clear to see that this building has been ill designed for today’s needs, and the multiple role it has to undertake”.

The Movement also notes that the International Day of Disabled Persons starts on December 3rd. This aims to promote an understanding of disability issues and mobilise support for the dignity, rights and well-being of persons with disabilities. It also seeks to increase awareness of gains to be derived from the integration of persons with disabilities in every aspect of political, social, economic and cultural life.

The theme of the Day, ‘E-Accessibility‘, is based on the goal of full and equal enjoyment of human rights and participation in society by persons with disabilities, established by the World Programme of Action concerning Disabled Persons, adopted by the UN General Assembly in 1982, of which additional information can be seen on the GLDM website’s news room.

A spokesperson for the GLDM added:


“We must add that the countdown of Gibraltar Government transposing into law the EU directive on Equality in Employment is still running and it has less than 25 days of its implementation. And the Disability Discrimination Act legislation, which was told to us by Government, it was hoping to have it on the statute book by December this year.”

The Gibraltar Local Disability Movement said it would like Government to promote disability issues regarding, the implementing directive, Disability Discrimination Act, and to sensitive policies, programs and projects and to promote public awareness on disabilities.

Source: Gibraltar Local Disability Movement (GLDM) Press Release - 06 November 2006 / The Gibraltar Chronicle - The Independent Daily First Published 1801

Related Articles and Links:

International Day of Disabled Persons

World Programme of Action concerning Disabled Persons

The European Social Charter

UN Declaration on the Rights of Disabled Persons

Disability Awareness in Action (The international disability & human rights network) - UN Convention to Promote & Protect the Rights & Dignity of Persons with Disabilities

Social Services Agency

03 November 2006 - Concerns over Social Services Agency are widespread, say Opposition party

02 November 2006 - GGR voices concern for the Blind

31 October 2006 - Mother of disabled boy speaks out against Social Services Agency

Read more Articles and News reports about Disability issues in Gibraltar

Read more Articles and News Reports about or related to the Gibraltar Local Disability Movement

Read more Articles and News reports about Social Services in Gibraltar

My Gibraltar Directory - Website Directory of Gibraltar and the Campo de Gibraltar

Comment on this News report - Click on the ‘Comments’ link below - You can also Discuss this Story in our Forum

EU accepts local disability movement petition

Wednesday, August 30th, 2006

Disability Society protest against Government shortcomings on Disability issues in GibraltarThe Gibraltar Local Disability Movement (GLDM) has received a letter from the European Union Committee on Petitions saying that a formal complaint that it submitted is admissible.

The GLDM was taking up the lack of application of an EU rule to Gibraltar with regard to measures for air travel by disabled and persons with reduced mobility.

The letter of European Union Committee on Petitions said it had considered the petition and decided that the issues which raised are admissible in accordance with the Rules of Procedure of the European Parliament, “insofar as the subject matter falls within the sphere of activities of the European Union”.

The Committee says it began its examination of the petition and decided to ask the European Commission to conduct a preliminary investigation of various aspect of the problem. The petition was also forwarded for information to the Committee on Transport and Tourism, so that the issues raised could be taken into account in the course of its activity. The Committee told the GLDM that it will continue its examination of the petition as soon as it is in receipt of the necessary information.

GLDM says it will continue to be vigilant and will submit intensive questioning to, in the case of disputed, and controversial, or doubtful matters affecting the disabled. “We must not forget that the Government has until 2 December 2006 to transpose into Gibraltar Law the provisions on age and disability discrimination of the EU directive on Equality in Employment.”

The Directive stipulates that “employers shall take appropriate measures, where needed in a particular case, to enable a person with a disability to have access to, participate in, or advance in employment.”

The GLDM says it hopes the Gibraltar Government will take notice of this as it has less than four months to prepare itself. They said that the Chief Minister has informed them that Disability Discrimination Act legislation is being drafted and was hoping to have it on the statute book by December this year.

“We would like to add that the government should make provisions for the business in Gibraltar to be able to make necessary access available, whether by EU social funds or by government incentives,” said Gordon Nelson, the groups chairman.

From The Gibraltar Chronicle - The Independent Daily First Published 1801

Related Articles and Links:

Gibraltar Local Disability Movement (GLDM)

European Union Committee on Petitions

The European Social Charter,

Regulation of The European Parliament concerning the rights of persons with reduced mobility when travelling by air: View as HTML View in .pdf format

UN Declaration on the Rights of Disabled Persons

Disability Awareness in Action (The international disability & human rights network) - UN Convention to Promote & Protect the Rights & Dignity of Persons with Disabilities

03 March 2006 - Disability Movement present Complaint Petition to EU Parliament

21 February 2006 - GGR submits Human Rights Report to EU

16 January 2006 - EU turns its back on Gibraltar’s disabled

26 January 2006 - EU Commissioners to review Gibraltar’s exclusion from disabled passengers Air travel legislation

Read more Articles and News stories about Disability issues in Gibraltar

Read more Articles and News Reports about or related to the Gibraltar Local Disability Movement

Comment on this News report - Click on the ‘Comments’ link below - You can also Discuss this Story in our Forum

Disability Society calls on Del Agua to join public debate

Saturday, June 10th, 2006

Disability Society protest against Government shortcomings on Disability issues in GibraltarThe Gibraltar Disability Society has invited Social Services minister Yvette del Agua to a public debate on issues of concern to local disabled people.

The invitation comes after the Government refuted as “politically highly-charged and demonstrably false” the Society’s claims that local services for disabled people were in crisis.

Yesterday, the Society said its damning assessment had been based on “careful and continued consultation with its members”, adding that it was only published after sufficient evidence had been collected.

“The membership felt that the issues were too serious and public awareness had to be raised,” it said in a statement.


“After careful consideration it was the Society’s decision to support its membership and proceed with a public demonstration.

This is something that our disabled members and their families did not take lightly.

These are the real issues that affect our members on a daily basis and not false politically charged statements.”

The Society said the focus of its criticism had been on services for disabled people, and not on social services as a whole “as the Minister suggests”.

Yesterday it reaffirmed its position on the poor state of many of those services, which it said were of critical importance to disabled people and their families. It rejected, for example, Mrs del Agua’s statement that a structured respite service existed in Gibraltar.

“In reality this service at this time is in total disarray,” the Society said.


“Never in the history of respite has there been such a significant breakdown in the service, with members crying out for support and not receiving any.

There are certain basic needs that all families with profoundly disabled family members need, respite being a crucial part.

This basic need has been totally neglected by Government and many families continue to suffer.”

The Society acknowledged and welcomed the fact that the Government is in the process of recruiting seven new permanent members of staff for the respite service but it added that this was something it had urged the Government to do for many years in order to avoid the current situation.

“It is clear therefore that a structured respite service is not in place as the Government is suggesting,” it said.

In its statement, the Society countered some of the specific points raised by the Government.
It said, for example, that while there had been some improvements in the way that the Dr Giraldi home was structured, this was no cause for celebration.


“Although a step in the right direction, this is by no means a reason for the Government to pat itself on the back, particularly as the rest of Europe by that time was disbanding institutions in favour of supported independent living.

Despite the achievements the Government feels it has made, it is still a fact that the Dr Giraldi home is not only full but has overflowed into the respite unit. This would imply absolutely no forward planning whatsoever.”

The Government is currently taking steps for two disabled people to enter into supported living, though this has not yet taken place and, according to the Society, has been delayed by over a year. Neither are there any evident plans to further this supported living scheme for other disabled members.

One of the key issues that the Society had focused on in its initial statement was the complete absence of legislation to protect the rights of disabled persons. But in its response this week the Government ‘very noticeably’ did not mention this issue at all, even though the Society had insisted that it was of “paramount” importance.

“The Disability Society welcomes the fact that the Minister for Social Affairs is open to further discussions regarding the improvements to disability services,” the Society’s statement said.


“We are happy that her department wishes to maintain good relations with the Society and develop any new initiatives which may emerge.

This has been the Society’s position all along.

The Society maintains that the issues raised in our last press statement were correct and we find it hard to understand how the Minister would perceive that the Society and its members were not being serious, factual and honest.

In view of this and in order to clarify all the issues raised we invite the Minister and her department to a public debate with our membership.”

From The Gibraltar Chronicle - The Independent Daily First Published 1801

Related Articles and Links:

06 June 2006 - Del Agua denies Government is failing disabled

30 May 2006 - GLDM support for Disability Society

27 May 2006 - House Session greeted by Disabled demonstration

Read more Articles and News stories about Disability issues in Gibraltar

Read more Articles and News Reports about or related to the Gibraltar Local Disability Movement

Read more Articles and News reports about Social Servicesin Gibraltar

View more images about the Disability Society anti-Government protest in our Gibraltar Pictures Gallery - Images courtesy of The Gibraltar Local Disability Movement (GLDM)

Comment on this News report - Click on the ‘Comments’ link below - You can also Discuss this Story in our Forum

GLDM support for Disability Society

Tuesday, May 30th, 2006

Disability Society protest against Government shortcomings on Disability issues in GibraltarFollowing the anti-Government demonstration organised by the Gibraltar Disability Society outside the House of Assembly last Friday morning, the Gibraltar Local Disability Movement (GLDM) issued a statement today, in support of the Society.


The Gibraltar Disability Society's anti-Government protesters demonstrating outside the House of Assembly on Friday 26th May 2006 - (Images courtesy of the Gibraltar Local Disability Movement - GLDM)
The GLDM said they “fully support The Disability Society and what it is trying to achieve”.

In their statement, Gordon Nelson, spokesperson for the Disability Movement said that everyone has witnessed, in the past few weeks, the way the Government have dismissed protests from various groups in Gibraltar, labelling these as “unfair, unbalanced and demonstrably incorrect”.

Mr Nelson highlights examples such as Housing Minister Clive Beltran’s “system of allocating housing to the elderly and to applicants who are medically categorized ‘A’ ” along with the dismissal of the survey commissioned by the TGWU Nursing Section, “were government thinks it does not accord with reality”, and the Government’s opposition to the TGWU Branch Officer Charles Sisarello”.

Mr Nelson says the Disability Society “has made many repeated pleas and suggestions from the families of disabled people to the government about there despair on the situation on the services offered at respite services”.


“The GLDM think that to have the government come out and imply that The Disability Society is being unfair, unbalanced and demonstrably incorrect, is a lack of understanding of the lengthy discourse of people and family’s with a disability.

The GLDM think the reasoning or the ability to reason is in spoken language, is longer than the sentence for a disabled and can be made simple.

Government can give justification on many issues, but what it must understand is the reasoning in the behavior of The Disability Society.

If we think clearly and coherently it is clear that things must not be working well in our society.

Ministry of Social and Civic Affairs, if it was, we would have not experience the emotions of the demonstrators outside House of Assembly on Friday morning.”

Mr Nelson adds that “it is important that the system of protecting the quality of life in Gibraltar be given to all sectors in our community and not just the basics”.


“It is important that fundamental law be in place to protect the vulnerable, as a matter of principle.

Any philosophical ideas that government have, must be seen in action and not in the activity of process of thinking.”

The GLDM spokesperson calls for “the establishment of governmental structures” that can offer help and advice to disabled persons, in particular on how to access Social benefits. He says these functions and its recourses must be established, as required under the European Social Charter, 529 UNTS 89, in force since February 1965 and quotes the following articles:

    Article 9 - The right to vocational guidance.
    Article 14 - The right to benefit from social welfare services
    Article 15 - The right of physically or mentally disabled persons to vocational training, rehabilitation and social resettlement
    Article 16 - The right of the family to social, legal and economic protection

Mr Nelson says the Government’s disability policies must take account of all successive stages in the integration process and all areas of community life, such as prevention, diagnosis, treatment, education, vocational guidance and training, employment, social integration, information and research.


“Failure to protect the rights of citizens with disabilities and improve their opportunities is a violation of human dignity.”

Mr Nelson added that he hopes the promised statement by Government, concerning the recent discontent expressed by disability groups, will show a commitment from Government to improve its performance on disability issues. However, what he thinks it will say is “that they have been improving its service, with things like:

  1. New Swimming Pool exclusively for elderly and disabled.
  2. Gibraltar’s pavements have been made ‘disable friendly[’
  3. A ’shopmobility’ has been established
  4. That this government has spent more than the previous government.
  5. Disability Discrimination Act legislation.

Mr Nelson said they communicated with the Minister for Social Affairs in February about the implementation of the Disability Discrimination Act. The GLDM received a reply this month from Mr D. Hook, Private Secretary to the Chief Minister, informing the GLDM that a “Disability Discrimination Act legislation is being drafted. Mr Hook’s response said:

“We (the Government) hope to have it (Disability Discrimination legislation) on the statute book by December this year.

Mr Hook added that he has asked the Ministry of Social Affairs to “set out in detail the structure of disability rights and benefits as it exists in Gibraltar and we are still awaiting a reply from Ministry of Social Affairs”.


The Gibraltar Disability Society's anti-Government protesters demonstrating outside the House of Assembly on Friday 26th May 2006 - (Images courtesy of the Gibraltar Local Disability Movement - GLDM)
The Gibraltar Local Disability Movement thinks that the government have lost “what all governments must never lose, and that is its people”. Mr Nelson said:


“Government needs to be more accessible and approachable. Government ministers may think that all the unhappiness around us today is due to Opposition, but in the case of The Disability Society it can’t justify this context”.

Mr Nelson said “a special Swimming Pool may be opening this week but what the government should have done is make all Swimming areas accessible”.


“So that persons with a disability can enjoy a better social integration with its family members with the possibility of choice.

Preference is a right that all persons have, but when it comes to people who have a disability, society needs to be more aware.

No one can’t put the blame on our society, it must be a part of government program to endorse the disabled in all public areas, and government should be seen motivating better social integration for the disabled as an obligation and not as an honourable thing.

Recognition and principles to the disabled recognition in the integration in our society acceptance should have a legal status, and we hope that disability should not be class as when it was when in the world had discrimination on grounds of race.

Disability should not be but on any one of the groups into which the world’s population can be divided on the basis of physical characteristics, and should belong to a group of humans who share the same physical features, that of the right of social integration and inclusion.”

From The Gibraltar Local Disability Movement (GLDM) - Press Release - 30 May 2006

Related Articles and Links:

The European Social Charter - 529 UNTS 89,

Disability Awareness in Action (The international disability & human rights network) - UN Convention to Promote & Protect the Rights & Dignity of Persons with Disabilities

27 May 2006 - House Session greeted by Disabled demonstration

26 May 2006 - Social Affairs Ministry to issue statement on Disability issues discontent next week

26 May 2006 - Social Services agency needs a ’shake-up’ says Union

25 May 2006 - Ministry confirms pay will continue tied to absenteeism in Social Services Agency row

25 May 2006 - Del Agua ‘hysterical’ says Opposition

25 May 2006 - New Gibraltar Democracy calls for support for Disability protest

24 May 2006 - Disability Society launches protest over ‘failed’ services

19 May 2006 - Government announces new Swimming facilities for Disabled

17 May 2006 - GGR makes EU Report public

15 March 2006 - Caruana accused of playing politics with disabled

06 March 2006 - Disability Movement present Complaint Petition to EU Parliament

26 January 2006 - EU Commissioners to review Gibraltar’s exclusion from disabled passengers Air travel legislation

Read more Articles and News stories about Disability issues in Gibraltar

Read more Articles and News Reports about or related to the Gibraltar Local Disability Movement

Read more Articles and News reports about Social Servicesin Gibraltar

View more images about the Disability Society anti-Government protest in our Gibraltar Pictures Gallery - Images courtesy of the Gibraltar Local Disability Movement - GLDM

Comment on this News report - Click on the ‘Comments’ link below - You can also Discuss this Story in our Forum